
I am also thinking about the labels we give each other. When I hear adults discussing other adults or even children, I'm amazed how quick some people are to call a child a "problem" or "spirited." Or when adults call another of their own "selfish," or "moronic." In most cases it seems that these labels are given out simply because an individual doesn't like or doesn't understand what another person does or says.
Most recently there has been a debate brewing around my home town near New Orleans. The controvery is surrounding labels and trademarks of the phrase "Who Dat" for Saints Football gear. Now, most of you may remember that I don't watch football or even consider myself a sports fan. But the topic of selling merchandise and the NFL trying to prevent vendors from placing the "Who Dat" slogan on clothing and other items does intrigues the writer and English major in me.
Would this be an issue if the Saints weren't going to the Superbowl in less than a week? Would anyone care? I find it comical and admirable to read that Louisiana Congressmen like David Vitter are even taking a stance on this issue, telling the NFL that they can sue him or he'll start his own t-shirt label that says, "Who Dat Says We Can't Print Who Dat."
That leads me to my thoughts and questions for the day.... Who really owns a label? And who decides what labels are worth?
The first question is tricky. Lawyers will argue one way and the public may argue a different verdict. Trademarks may be in place but they often have a gray area. There is so much debate over this topic that I won't even dive into the thousands of cases over the past decade. Remember when author J.K. Rowling was upset over her last Harry Potter book leaking out over the internet? How about that Metallica vs. Napster case, anyone? There's just too many examples to discuss.
The second question is easier to answer though. Who decides the value of a label, word or item? Well, we do, of course.
We decide if something is valuable and worth the price listed on the tag. We determine if the words someone says has any merit. Do you believe in it? How bad do you want it? What is it worth to you? Are you willing to go against the grain and even stir up trouble by "owning" or buying a particular thing, phrase or label?
As I organized my closet over the weekend, finally clearing a path where I could walk inside, I ran my fingers through all my clothing. Most of them are clearance items. You know, the JC Penney or Sears BOGO specials. But there are a few skirts or tops (even shoes) that I didn't care what the price was, I just had to have them. Even though they sit there collecting dust now.

In fact, to this day, my mom still brings up that $200 homecoming suit that I begged to have my senior year of high school. That top, skirt and matching hat that I would die if I didn't get. The beautiful beige ensemble that I wanted to wear proudly across that football field for the big homecoming football game. Football that I don't give a flip about, not then or now. Those three minutes of glory have long been forgotten, but my mom still reminds me of that hefty price tag she paid for my happiness.
That 1995 homecoming suit and those articles of clothing hanging on my shelves mean very little unless I place value in them. A Coach purse and Jimmy Choo shoes mean nothing to me today but they are everything to Carrie Bradshaw in Sex and the City. Neither one of us is right or wrong in our choices. We simply value things differently.
As I get older, my tastes and values are changing. Right now, I'm more concerned with my own personal values rather than the articles of clothing and "stuff" sitting inside my house.
I'm also trying hard to avoid reading into or attaching labels to other people. Including other children and my own daughter. I'm tired of hearing negative things being said about this person or that thing. I'm not taking stock in that kind of behavior anymore.
And I am no longer allowing other people to label me or my kid. No one else (except my husband Kirk) really knows who I am or who Vivian is as a person anyway. Why should I listen to others' opinions? They will most likely provide no value to me. For example, if someone calls my Vivian "difficult," (as Vivian's former day care director said on our last day there), it will not mean anything, unless I let it get to me. I don't have to believe what someone else says. If I don't value the statement, the person or the label, then I don't have to "buy" it.
I'm learning these lessons the hard way. But at least I'm learning them now.
Labels and values can apply to so much in life. I'm seeing that more and more these days. And I'm trusting my instincts to know what labels are important to me and how they affect my values.
Now, don't get me wrong. I still buy labels from time to time. I may even offer someone a label too. Just last week, I had a small shopping spree and bought nothing but name brands. (see below)

A "treat yourself trip" from time to time can make you feel good. If you had two gift cards, like I did, then it makes the store visits even more enjoyable. :-)
Most importantly though, I valued the experience in the stores more than the items I purchased. I had a few hours of Mandy time to myself (while Viv was being cared for at a Mother's Day Out program). So I had nearly four hours where I could focus on just my own needs and wants. I could relax and breathe easier. There was no rushing around. No worrying about anyone else for a change.
That time to reflect on my values, while I just happend to buy a few labels,..... well I guess you can call that priceless.








13 comments:
So glad you got a four hour break..sometimes it can feel like 40 hours.
Have a great week!
Oh boy, can labels be dangerous. I have found that any sort of label can get someone in trouble, even if it is as simple as calling someone shy.
I do my best to stay far, far away from labels. The seem to put people in boxes, and I am sure no one likes it.
Oh, and someone called Viv difficult? Did they forget that she is a toddler?
Seems ridiculous to me.
I know labels far too well, and sadly they have been towards my 3 yr old daughter and a very mean hard to work with person (oops did I just label her?) Anyways I feel I am a mom to protect my kids from labels as best I can. Also love the homecoming suit story. My dad does the same thing about a Homecoming dress my mom bought me for $200 and that we found another like 10 min later that we liked better, but the store wouldn't let us return the first one, so yeah a $200 dress that was never worn :) Love reading your blog.
As a mom, I'm always on the lookout when schools or teachers want to label a kid. Who knows how that label will follow them?
I have started typing 3 times of what I wanted to reply on this and each time I could feel myself wanting to go into this long spill about how I feel about this very subject and all I want to say is BRAVO!!! DITTO for me!!! Wow you hit the nail on the head with this one! I have family and friends that "label" my sons in one way or another and sometimes even several labels. I ignore it most of the time because like you say "I decide the value of the label". So tell me this... how do you handle the label when you're child hears it and you want to counteract what was said about them?
What a great post!
My boss' son is "energetic" and "impulsive" and his kindergarten teacher(it was her first year teaching) had a hard time handling him. This year his first grade teacher is much more experienced and has helped him alot. However, the school is still pushing for an evaluation....and therefore a label, so they can properly "deal with" his behavior(i.e. get more money by saying he needs special attention). My boss and his wife have finally agreed and I belive the evaluation is next week. They are worried about labeling their son but are hoping it will help them and the teachers understand his behavior better. I can tell my boss is still very nervous about applying a label to his kid. --I don't think there's anything wrong with the kid; sure he's a little hyper sometimes, but he's SIX! He's the youngest in his class and eventually he'll mature. Also, he's doing great academically.
I think this is the longest comment I've ever left!
Hi Tonya,
That is a very good question you asked about how to handle it when your children hear labels, especially negative ones. I haven't gone through that yet since Viv is younger than your two boys.
But I imagine that I'd talk to her honestly about it. I'd ask her, "What do you think about that person calling you ____? Is that how you see yourself?"
If she says "no" then we'd talk about why she doesn't see herself that way and how she can rise above people's criticisms of her.
If she says, "yes" or "I'm not sure," then I'd talk to her about self image and how she could improve it. I'd also tell her about how much I love her and how I see her as a person. We'd discuss how all her loved ones view her and how we hope that is how she'll someday see herself. And if necessary, then we'd discuss ways to improve her self image and how she could feel better about herself.
Anyway, that's what I think I would do. I hope this helps you.
Hugs to you and the boys. No matter what anyone says to your or to them, your love for each other cannot be taken away!
All the best to you,
Mandy
These days I'm too busy to comjure up labels for people. As for stuff I've found the older I get the less I need or want.
I'm glad you got some time for yourself. It is very important for all of us.
mamacita:
first, thank YOu for the fabulous comment on monday, you are so lovely, thoughtful and kind, thank you thank you thank you!
second, this is a fabulously written and thought provoking post! You are right, some random day care worker calling Viv difficult isn't important nor meaningful and where does she get off trying to put a stamp on your daughter and her personality. people like that need to get a life, and in general, love your message on this post :)
have a great day Mandy!
ps it is a girl :)
Good for you on not accepting Labels random people try to put on you or your family! :-)
It can be easy to listen to what others say, even if we say we don't at the time, so I'm so happy you've proactively chose not to pay attention or let it define you.
Well said!
I used to be very label conscious, but I become a little less so every year. What does it mean? Sometimes it means quality - and sometimes that's what I want. But for something trendy? Who cares if it will last 20 years - you're only going to wear it one season!
As for labeling people? Never really a good plan. A necessary evil sometimes, however, when it comes to acquiring funding for programs. That's the only time I can think of that it's beneficial...
Post a Comment